Healthcare Recovery Audit: Overview, Cost, and Benefits

What is a Healthcare Recovery Audit

A healthcare recovery audit assesses a healthcare system or hospital's financial processes and transactions. This audit aims to identify opportunities to improve efficiency and recover any overpayments or errors. An external auditor or consulting firm typically conducts it to address inefficiencies in financial processes.

Several reasons make healthcare recovery audits crucial. One reason is to improve efficiency and reduce costs. By identifying issues and overpayments, the healthcare system or hospital can save money and streamline operations. Another reason is mitigating financial risks by ensuring contract compliance and proper pricing with suppliers.

Recovery audit professionals possess extensive expertise in multiple ERPs, data sets, and complex contracts. This broad experience includes auditing GPO distributors and local supplier purchases, payments, Rx experience, and pricing analysis. They work within and across suppliers to pinpoint overpayments and trends.

The audit covers various areas:

  1. GPO Distributors And Local Supplier Purchases: Auditors review transactions from Group Purchasing Organizations and local suppliers.
  2. Payments: Experts analyze payment records to find discrepancies.
  3. Rx Experience: The audit examines pharmacy-related transactions to identify overpayments.
  4. Data Proficiency: Utilizing multiple datasets and ERP systems, auditors ensure comprehensive coverage.
  5. Pricing Overpayment And Trend Analysis: Auditors compare pricing across suppliers to uncover overpayments.

By focusing on these areas, recovery audits help hospitals and healthcare systems achieve financial accuracy. This process involves significant experience and proven techniques to deliver results. For healthcare systems, such audits are indispensable for maintaining financial health and operational efficiency.

The role of these audits extends beyond merely recovering funds. They help establish better financial practices, leading to long-term cost savings and operational improvements. In an industry with tight margins, the benefits of a thorough recovery audit cannot be overstated.

Ben Evans

Reviewed by Ben Evans, CPA, CCA, and President of Auditec Solutions.

Is your business at risk for compliance fraud?

Download our FREE whitepaper to learn how much money you could be losing. In this free whitepaper you will learn about the most common contract compliance over billings and other major red flags to look out for.

Understanding Healthcare Recovery Audits

The Role of Recovery Audit Contractors

Recovery Audit Contractors (RACs) scrutinize medical records, billing information, and other relevant documents to identify improper payments. This process, introduced in 2005 by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), aims to enhance the accuracy and efficiency of healthcare payments. RACs operate on a contingency fee basis, receiving payment for identifying both overpayments and underpayments. Over the years, the role of RACs has evolved, reflecting changes in regulatory requirements and areas of focus.

If a payment discrepancy is found, RACs adjust it by either recouping overpayments or reimbursing underpayments. They typically request up to ten medical records from a provider within 45 days. The review period stretches up to three years, though CMS limits this to six months under certain conditions. Providers can choose to pay a disputed amount via check within 30 days, allow recoupment from future payments, or request an extended payment plan.

Key Areas of Focus in Recovery Audits

RAC audits concentrate on areas where improper payments are likely to occur. These include coding errors, medical necessity, and compliance with Medicare billing requirements. By consistently reviewing these areas, RACs can identify patterns of incorrect billing practices and prevent future errors.

Medical necessity reviews determine whether services provided align with established guidelines. Coding audits ensure that procedures and diagnoses are accurately represented. Payment audits focus on verifying that the amounts billed match the services rendered.

RACs frequently update their list of target issues on their websites. Once CMS approves new issues, RACs begin auditing claims related to those concerns. This proactive approach helps healthcare providers stay compliant with evolving regulations and avoid financial pitfalls.

RAC audits play a crucial role in maintaining financial integrity within healthcare systems. By identifying and correcting improper payments, RACs not only recover lost funds but also ensure ongoing compliance with healthcare regulations.

Cost of a Healthcare Recovery Audit

The cost of a healthcare recovery audit can vary based on several factors, including the size of the healthcare system, the extent of the audit, and the pricing model employed by the auditing firm. Generally, recovery audits may be conducted on a contingency fee basis or a fixed fee arrangement.

Contingency Fee Basis:
In a contingency fee model, the auditing firm charges a percentage of the recovered amounts as its fee. This model can be advantageous for healthcare organizations with limited upfront budgets. Since the fee is based on the success of the audit, there is a strong incentive for the auditor to maximize recoveries. For example, if an auditor identifies $1 million in recoveries and charges a 15% fee, the healthcare organization pays $150,000.

Fixed Fee Arrangement:
Alternatively, some firms offer a fixed fee structure, which involves a predetermined charge regardless of the amount recovered. This model provides more predictability in budgeting but may require a considerable upfront investment. Large healthcare systems might prefer fixed fees to avoid variable costs associated with contingency arrangements.

  1. Scope of Audit: More comprehensive audits that scrutinize multiple financial areas usually cost more than limited-scope reviews.
  2. Size of Organization: Larger healthcare organizations typically face higher audit fees due to the complexity and volume of transactions.
  3. Duration: Longer audits necessitate more resources, increasing the cost.
  4. Specific Needs: Custom audit services tailored to particular financial processes or issues may add to the overall expense.

Although recovery audits involve costs, the potential savings from identifying and correcting errors can outweigh these expenses. When financial inaccuracies are rectified, healthcare organizations can reinvest recovered funds into patient care and operational improvements, ensuring long-term financial stability and efficiency.

Types of Healthcare Recovery Audits

Automated Audits

Automated audits focus on identifying clear policy or coding violations in billing data. These audits are efficient since they don't require additional documentation from providers. They use data-driven algorithms and analytics to analyze large volumes of claims rapidly. This process pinpoints errors, such as services billed that aren't covered by Medicare. Though less labor-intensive than complex audits, automated audits demand high accuracy and attention to detail from the Recovery Audit Contractors (RACs).

Complex Audits

Complex audits provide a detailed review of medical records and other documentation when billing data alone doesn't suffice. These audits verify the medical necessity of services and the appropriateness of claims by requesting additional documentation from providers. This includes medical records, treatment plans, and relevant documents. Recovery Audit Contractors then scrutinize this documentation to ensure services were medically necessary and billed correctly. While more labor-intensive and time-consuming, complex audits offer a thorough examination that can uncover issues not visible in billing data.

The Impact of Recovery Audits on Healthcare Providers

Financial Implications

Recovery audits have notable financial consequences for healthcare providers. When an audit identifies overpayments, providers must return the excess funds to Medicare. In many cases, these amounts can reach millions of dollars, creating significant financial risk. For example, in FY 2021, RAC contractors recovered over $2 billion in improper payments. Conversely, if underpayments are identified, providers may receive additional reimbursements, enhancing their financial situation. Overall, the potential for both financial losses and gains highlights the importance of accurate billing practices and financial oversight in healthcare.

Administrative Challenges

Recovery audits impose a substantial administrative burden on healthcare providers. Responding to audit requests requires considerable time and resources. Providers need to gather and submit relevant documentation, communicate with the RAC, and potentially challenge audit findings. This work can divert resources from patient care and other critical functions. According to the American Hospital Association, hospitals spend hundreds of thousands of dollars annually—sometimes millions—on RAC appeals, audits, and denials. These administrative costs could be better allocated toward improving patient care and operational efficiency. The challenge of balancing compliance with audit requirements and maintaining optimal patient care remains a critical issue for healthcare providers.

Preparing for a Healthcare Recovery Audit

Best Practices for Healthcare Providers

Implementing specific practices can streamline the audit process and minimize disruptions. One key best practice is maintaining organized and accurate records. Auditors often request detailed documentation, so having all records readily accessible can expedite the review. Training staff on compliance and audit procedures is equally crucial. This ensures everyone knows their role and can act efficiently.

Another best practice involves routine self-audits. By periodically reviewing their own records and billing processes, providers can identify and rectify discrepancies before an external audit occurs. Using specialized software for tracking and managing claims can further enhance accuracy and efficiency. Lastly, communicating with the RAC for your region ensures they're informed of the correct contact points for audit-related documentation, reducing potential delays.

The Importance of Documentation

Complete and precise documentation is vital during a healthcare recovery audit. Comprehensive medical records and billing information provide a clear trail that auditors can follow, reducing the risk of misinterpretation or errors. Providers should ensure that all entries are detailed, including diagnosis codes, treatment plans, and billing codes.

Proper documentation also supports the appeal process if there's a disagreement with audit findings. Having robust and well-organized records simplifies building a case for appeal. Moreover, during times of operational changes or team restructuring, accurate documentation helps in maintaining continuity and consistency.

Keeping documentation up-to-date with current billing and coding requirements, as well as statutory and regulatory provisions, is essential for ensuring compliance. This proactive approach can significantly reduce the impact of audits on operations and finances.

Navigating the Recovery Audit Appeals Process

Steps to Appeal a Recovery Audit Decision

When faced with a recovery audit decision, understanding the appeal process is crucial for any healthcare provider. Initially, review the detailed reason for the denial provided by the Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC). Collect all relevant documentation, including medical records and billing information, to support the claim's validity. Submit a request for redetermination by filing it within the specified timeframe, generally within 120 days from the initial denial notice.

Next, move to the reconsideration phase if the redetermination is unfavorable. At this stage, an independent contractor from the Qualified Independent Contractor (QIC) will examine the appeal. Be prepared with comprehensive documentation and clear arguments to strengthen your position. The reconsideration request must be filed within 180 days of the redetermination decision.

If you receive an adverse reconsideration determination, you can request a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). The appeal should be filed within 60 days of the reconsideration outcome. Prepare all required evidence meticulously, as the ALJ will review it during the hearing process.

In cases where the ALJ decision is not in favor, proceed to the Medicare Appeals Council (MAC). File this within 60 days of the ALJ’s decision. Finally, if necessary, escalate the appeal to the Federal District Court by filing within 60 days of the MAC’s decision. Each step requires specific forms and strict adherence to deadlines, ensuring your documentation is comprehensive and clearly substantiates the care provided.

Understanding the Timeline

Navigating the timelines of RAC appeals is pivotal for a successful outcome. From the date of initial denial, the first level of appeal, Redetermination, allows a window of 120 days. Timely submission ensures that your appeal moves forward without delays.

The second level, Reconsideration, must be filed within 180 days following the redetermination decision. This phase involves a more in-depth review by the QIC, requiring detailed evidence and solid arguments.

The third level, the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) hearing, narrows the timeline to 60 days from the reconsideration decision. Given its formal nature, thorough preparation is key to presenting your case effectively.

If the ALJ’s decision is unsatisfactory, escalate to the Medicare Appeals Council (MAC) within 60 days. Lastly, for a Federal District Court review, submit within 60 days from the MAC decision. Adhering to these timelines ensures the integrity of your appeal process and improves the likelihood of a favorable outcome.

The Future of Recovery Audits

Healthcare recovery audits are essential for ensuring financial accuracy and compliance. As the industry evolves, the role of Recovery Audit Contractors (RACs) will continue to be pivotal in refining financial processes. Staying informed about the appeals process and maintaining rigorous documentation is key to navigating audits effectively. With ongoing advancements in technology and data analytics, the future of recovery audits promises to be more efficient and precise. By embracing these changes, healthcare providers can better manage their financial health and focus on delivering quality patient care.

If you want to continue learning more about recovery audit check out our other resources found below.

Contract Compliance Audit

Construction Audit

Accounts Payable Recovery Audit

Recovery Audit

Contract Compliance

Ensuring trust through compliance: Auditing your contracts for peace of mind.